Accountancy Europe has responded to the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) on the Exposure Draft for Risk Mitigation Accounting (RMA).
While we generally agree with the objective of reflecting the economic effects of net repricing risk management, we highlight several tensions with the accounting Conceptual Framework – most notably regarding the level of application. We welcome applying RMA at the level where risk is actually managed (frequently at subsidiaries). However, the Board must clarify how to treat intragroup cash transactions that are included in a subsidiary’s risk strategy but eliminated upon consolidation.
We believe faithfully depicting actual risk management requires expanding the scope of eligible instruments, such as including lease receivables held in the banking book regardless of their accounting classification.
We support recognising any over-hedging (where designated derivatives exceed the net repricing risk exposure) directly in profit or loss. Additionally, the core concept of “unexpected changes” requires clear definition before choosing between a tracking mechanism or a refined impairment-style test – given that the currently proposed excess test is too flawed to maintain.
While we encourage the Board to maintain momentum on this important project, the significance of the required changes – including clarifications on option-based strategies and non-zero fair value derivatives – warrants re-exposing the revised model.