Take a look at Accountancy Europe’s response to EFRAG’s public consultation questionnaire regarding the ESRS-40a.
Accountancy Europe has responded to EFRAG’s public consultation questionnaire on the draft European Sustainability Reporting Standards for non-EU companies under Article 40a of the Accounting Directive (ESRS-40a).
We appreciate the standards aim to serve the CSRD’s level playing field objective whilst addressing proportionality following the extra-territoriality challenges. Our response highlights the need for proportionate, practical and decision-useful standards that deliver on the intended objectives and consider users and decisions they make, as well as the international state of play in sustainability reporting.
We support the objective of proportionality, but believe that the proposed mixed approach, which allows global reporting for certain sustainability impacts with EU-focused disclosures for others, raised conceptual and practical challenges.
We believe that the propose mixed approach hinders comparability and understandability, and question whether the impacts are faithfully represented and whether the resulting report is relevant for users. In addition, operationalising the mixed approach may require many assumptions and adaptation in existing systems and processes, which may ultimately raise burden and assurance challenges.
Accountancy Europe supports allowing more flexibility for companies to leverage their existing sustainability reports for the purpose of their ESRS-40a report. Ideally, non-EU companies could use their ISSB-based sustainability reports, and supplement with additional disclosures needed for ESRS-40a purposes.
We also encourage the European Commission to prioritise equivalence mechanisms with jurisdictions already requiring ISSB-based standards, to fully eliminate double reporting, reduce reporting burden and support the competitiveness of EU businesses.